A common situation that home inspectors face is a GFCI receptacle that trips using its test button, but does not trip using the inspector’s external tester. This generally indicates a wiring problem such as:
- Reversal of line and load conductors (Connected to wrong terminals on receptacle)
- Open grounding conductor
- Reversed polarity
Combination testers will detect some of these wiring faults, but single function GFCI testers will not.
If the line and load connections are reversed at the receptacle, the receptacle will remain energized after the device trips. This is a common wiring error. According to GFCI tester literature, a reversed ground and neutral will produce the same result; but actual tests performed by home inspectors differ from this information. An external tester used by an inspector does create an actual ground fault by diverting current to the grounding conductor. If there is no grounding conductor present in the circuit, or if its disconnected, the external tester will indicate that the device is not working, when in fact, it may be.
UNDERGROUND RECEPTACLES
Risk for the Inspector
Testing ungrounded receptacles does create some risk for the inspector. Here’s why: The GFCI tester operates by momentarily connecting the hot and grounding conductors. The current will pass to anything grounded, such as the receptacle cover or metal box (as commonly found outdoors). If the inspector is touching the grounded metal box, or perhaps holding open the metal cover over an outdoor receptacle, he will receive a shock when using the tester.
More GFCI Facts
Another little known fact is that GFCI devices are required to detect a grounded neutral so as to assure that there is no return path on the neutral in the event of a ground fault. Current returning on the neutral could reduce the difference in current being detected, and prevent the device from operating.
It is permissible to install a GFCI receptacle in an existing 2 wire ungrounded circuit. Many electricians are unaware that this is acceptable. They will incorrectly insist that a grounding conductor is necessary for the device to operate.